Domain reputation check: How to check and improve your score

Your domain reputation determines inbox placement. Learn how to check your domain reputation score, what impacts it, and how to improve it.
Domain Reputation Check

TLDR: There’s no single domain reputation score. To check your domain reputation, look at your authentication status, blocklist listings, mailbox provider data, and complaint and bounce rates. Google retired its domain reputation dashboard in 2025, so spam rate is now the Gmail number to watch.


Your domain reputation is the behind-the-scenes factor that determines whether your email campaigns will fly or flop. A good reputation boosts your chances of landing in the inbox, while a poor reputation can land you in the spam folder from the get-go.

Mailbox providers like Gmail, Yahoo, and Microsoft use domain reputation to judge your email-sending practices. A strong reputation means your messages reach your audience. A poor reputation means they don’t, no matter how good your content is.

The tricky part is that domain reputation isn’t a single number you can look up in one place. It’s a composite of factors (spam complaints, engagement rates, authentication status, and sending patterns) evaluated differently by each provider. To get a complete picture, you need to check multiple sources.

Below, we’ll walk you through how to check your domain reputation using free tools, explain what impacts your score, and show you how to improve your email domain reputation if it’s taken a hit.

Want the quickest check first? Enter your domain to see if its email authentication is set up correctly. Authentication is one input to your reputation, and it’s the one you can fix today.

Check your
domain now

Enter your domain to see if it’s vulnerable to spoofing or if others are sending emails on your behalf. Instantly check your DMARC, SPF, and BIMI status with a detailed security report.

You’re not fully protected, learn more here.

Check your
domain now

Enter your domain to see if it’s vulnerable to spoofing or if others are sending emails on your behalf. Instantly check your DMARC, SPF, and BIMI status with a detailed security report.

You’re not fully protected, learn more here.

Check your
domain now

Enter your domain to see if it’s vulnerable to spoofing or if others are sending emails on your behalf. Instantly check your DMARC, SPF, and BIMI status with a detailed security report.

You’re not fully protected, learn more here.

View Full Report

Your Domain

Not protected AGAINST IMPERSONATION ATTACKS

DMARC NOT AT ENFORCEMENT

exampledomain1.com

Authentication Status for January 10, 2025

DMARC at Enforcement

SPF Record Configured

BIMI Ready

exampledomain1.com

Authentication Status for January 10, 2025

DMARC at Enforcement

SPF Record Configured

BIMI Ready

What is domain reputation?

Domain reputation is the level of trust mailbox providers place in your sending domain, based on how recipients have reacted to your email messages over time. Gmail, Yahoo Mail, and Outlook each keep their own version of it, and they use it to decide if a message goes to the inbox, the spam folder, or nowhere at all.

It works a lot like a credit history. Nobody hands you the full file, each lender weighs it a little differently, and it takes far longer to rebuild than to damage.

What affects your domain reputation

Mailbox providers weigh six things. One of them, authentication, covers three protocols:

  1. Sender Policy Framework (SPF)
  2. DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM)
  3. Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC).
FactorWhat mailbox providers look atWhat to aim for
Spam complaintsHow often recipients mark your messages as spamUnder 0.1%, and never 0.3% or higher
EngagementOpens, clicks, replies, and messages rescued from spam, compared with deletes and ignoresSteady or rising engagement from the people you send to
Sending patternsVolume and frequency over timePredictable volume with gradual increases
AuthenticationSPF, DKIM, and DMARC resultsEvery sending service passing, with DMARC at enforcement
List qualityBounces, spam trap hits, and inactive addressesOpt-in lists that you clean regularly
InfrastructureSending IP history, DNS records, and reverse DNSClean IP addresses and complete DNS records

Spam complaints move the fastest. Google and Yahoo publish their thresholds: Stay under 0.3% to keep delivering, and aim for under 0.1%.

The good news? You have direct control over these factors. Start by checking your current domain reputation (we can help with that), then work on improving the areas where you’re falling short.

Domain reputation vs. IP reputation

Mailbox providers track two reputations for every sender. Domain reputation follows your domain wherever you send from. IP reputation belongs to the server address your messages leave from, and on a shared IP address, you inherit some of your neighbors’ behavior.

Domain reputationIP reputation
Tied toYour sending domainThe IP address of the sending server
Follows you to a new email service provider (ESP)YesNo
Shared with other sendersNoOften, on shared IP addresses
Where to check itGoogle Postmaster Tools, domain blocklistsSender Score, Microsoft SNDS, Cisco Talos, IP blocklists

Domain reputation carries more weight than it used to, so a new ESP or a new IP address won’t wipe the slate clean.

How do you check your domain reputation?

No single source sees your whole reputation, so you check it by combining a few free ones. Each answers a different question:

SourceWhat it tells youWhat you get back
Valimail Domain CheckerYour DMARC, SPF, and BIMI statusPass or fail for each protocol
Google Postmaster ToolsHow Gmail sees your domain: spam rate, authentication, delivery errors, and compliance with sender requirementsA spam rate percentage and a compliance status
Spamhaus reputation checkerIf your domain or IP address is on a Spamhaus blocklistListed or not listed
Sender ScoreThe reputation of your sending IP addressesA score from 0 to 100
Microsoft SNDSComplaint rates and spam trap hits for IP addresses sending to Outlook.comA color-coded filter status
Cisco TalosThe email reputation of your sending IP addressesGood, Neutral, or Poor

A healthy domain reputation is often indicated by high scores on reputation databases (typically closer to their maximum values) and positive feedback from email service providers’ diagnostic tools. This suggests your emails are generally well-received, with minimal spam complaints and strong engagement metrics.

Conversely, a poor domain reputation is marked by low scores on reputation databases and negative indicators from diagnostic tools, such as high spam complaint rates or frequent authentication failures.

Your email domain reputation directly influences your email deliverability. A healthy reputation opens doors, ensuring your messages reach their intended destinations—your audience’s inboxes. A poor reputation, however, can lead to your emails being sidelined into spam folders or blocked, significantly reducing your ability to engage with your audience.

Domain reputation check: step-by-step

Checking your domain reputation isn’t a one-and-done process. It requires looking at several data points across different platforms to get a complete picture. Here’s how to do a proper domain reputation check:

1: Check your authentication setup

Before diving into reputation tools, verify your domain’s basic authentication setup:

  1. Verify SPF records: Ensure your Sender Policy Framework record lists all authorized sending services.
  2. Confirm DKIM is properly configured: Your DomainKeys Identified Mail signature should be correctly set up for all major sending services.
  3. Check DMARC policy: Your Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance should ideally be set to enforcement (p=reject or p=quarantine).
  4. Validate BIMI status: If you’re using Brand Indicators for Message Identification, make sure it’s properly implemented.

You can use Valimail’s Domain Checker to quickly check all these authentication protocols at once.

2: Check blocklist status

Blocklists are databases of IPs and domains that have been reported for sending spam. Being listed on even one major blocklist can severely damage your deliverability:

  1. Use MXToolbox’s Blacklist Check (enter your domain or IP address)
  2. Check Multiple RBL (Real-time Blackhole List) status using MultiRBL
  3. Review the Spamhaus Blocklist to ensure you’re not listed
  4. Check your Barracuda reputation status

If you’re listed on any blocklist, follow the specific removal procedures for that service immediately.

3: Assess provider-specific reputation

Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo each share some of what they see:

  1. Google Postmaster Tools:
    • Verify your sending domain
    • Check the compliance status dashboard for any failed sender requirement
    • Watch your spam rate (under 0.1% is healthy, and 0.3% is the line to stay under)
    • Review the authentication and delivery errors dashboards
  2. Microsoft Smart Network Data Services (SNDS):
    • Register your sending IP addresses
    • Review complaint rates and spam trap hits
    • Check your filter status
  3. Yahoo Sender Hub:
    • Enroll your DKIM domains in the complaint feedback loop
    • Review which campaigns generate complaints

Google no longer shows a Bad, Low, Medium, or High reputation rating. If Gmail starts rejecting messages for low reputation, you’ll see it in the delivery errors dashboard and in your bounce logs.

4: Use third-party reputation tools

Independent services rate the IP addresses you send from:

  1. Sender Score (by Validity):
    • Look up your sending IP addresses for a score from 0 to 100
    • Treat anything below 70 as a problem to investigate
    • Review the factors behind the score
  2. Cisco Talos:
    • Check if your sending IP addresses are rated Good, Neutral, or Poor
    • Review volume history and sending patterns

If you send through a shared IP address, these scores reflect every sender in the pool.

5: Analyze your engagement metrics

Your own sending data often shows trouble before any outside source does. Compare each metric with your own baseline:

  1. Spam complaint rate: Keep it under 0.1%
  2. Bounce rate: A rising hard bounce rate points to a list quality problem
  3. Click-through and reply rates: More reliable than opens, which privacy features inflate
  4. Unsubscribe rate: A spike after one campaign tells you which message missed

A steady slide across these numbers is usually the first sign of a declining domain reputation.ion.

6: Interpret your findings

Once you’ve gathered data from multiple sources, look for patterns:

  • Excellent reputation: High scores across tools, no blocklisting, strong authentication, good engagement
  • Good reputation: Some variation in scores, but generally positive, complete authentication, decent engagement
  • Fair reputation: Mixed scores, possible minor blocklisting, adequate authentication, mediocre engagement
  • Poor reputation: Low scores, multiple blocklists, incomplete authentication, poor engagement

There’s no universal number, so a good domain reputation score means a healthy result from each source:

SourceHealthyNeeds attention
Gmail spam rate (Postmaster Tools)Under 0.1%0.3% or higher
Gmail compliance statusEvery requirement metAny requirement flagged
DMARCp=quarantine or p=reject, with all senders alignedp=none, or legitimate senders failing
BlocklistsNot listedListed anywhere
Sender Score80 or higherBelow 70
Cisco TalosGoodPoor

Want to check your domain reputation right now? Try our free Domain Reputation Check tool to get started.

6 warning signs of a damaged domain reputation

Your email program will show signs of trouble before your domain reputation tanks completely. Here are the warning signs to watch for:

  1. Delivery rates suddenly drop: Your emails start bouncing more than usual, or you notice they’re taking longer to deliver. If you typically see 98% delivery rates and suddenly drop to 90% or below, something’s wrong with your reputation.
  2. Engagement nosedives: When your normally active subscribers go quiet, it’s a red flag. Pay attention if your open rates drop more than 2-3 percentage points below your usual average, especially if it happens suddenly.
  3. Authentication starts failing: Unexpected SPF, DKIM, or DMARC failures could mean someone is spoofing your domain. This is especially concerning if you see authorization failures from IP addresses you don’t recognize.
  4. Blocklist appearances: Finding your domain on email blocklists is like getting multiple speeding tickets—one might be bad luck, but several suggest a pattern. Regular blocklist checks should be part of your email monitoring routine.
  5. Spam folder problems: When your emails land in spam folders, even when sent to engaged subscribers or business partners, your reputation is likely suffering. This is particularly concerning if it happens across multiple email providers.
  6. Unusual sending patterns: Unexpected spikes in sending volume or emails going out at odd hours could mean someone is hijacking your domain. Keep an eye on your DMARC reports to spot unauthorized senders early.

Notice any of these warning signs? Run a quick domain check to get a clear picture of what’s going on and what needs fixing first.

How to improve your email domain reputation

Sometimes, you’ll need to take action to address a poor domain reputation and get your score headed in the right direction. This will require a few proactive and ongoing maintenance actions. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • Implement SPF, DKIM, and DMARC: These email authentication protocols verify that your emails are genuinely from you, building trust with email service providers and your recipients. Sender Policy Framework (SPF) prevents email spoofing, DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) adds a digital signature to your emails, and Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC) ties the first two together with a set of policies and reporting mechanisms that improve and protect your domain’s reputation.
  • Regularly update your records: Keep your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records up to date to ensure your emails are consistently authenticated. This helps maintain your domain’s reputation and deliverability.
  • Build lists the right way: Only send messages to users who have explicitly opted in to receive communications from you. This best practice complies with marketing regulations, boosts engagement, and reduces spam reports.
  • Clean your lists frequently: Routinely remove inactive or unengaged subscribers from your mailing list. This helps improve your engagement rates and reduces the risk of spam complaints.
  • Track opens, clicks, and interactions: Regularly review your email campaign metrics to understand how your audience engages with your content. High engagement rates are a positive signal to mailbox providers about the quality and relevance of your emails.
  • Adjust based on performance: Use engagement data to refine your email strategy. Adjust your approach accordingly if certain types of content or sending times result in higher engagement.
  • Stay informed about your domain reputation: Use domain reputation tools regularly to monitor how your domain is perceived. This will help you catch and address any issues before they escalate.

Protect your email domain reputation with Valimail

Good sending habits protect most of your reputation. The part they can’t cover is who else is sending as your domain. A forgotten marketing platform or a spoofer can run up complaints under your name, and none of it shows in your ESP’s dashboard.

Valimail closes that gap:

  • Valimail Monitor (free): Shows every service sending as your domain by name, and which ones pass or fail authentication
  • Valimail Enforce: Automates SPF, DKIM, and DMARC management and gets you to DMARC enforcement, so unauthorized messages are blocked before they reach anyone

Start with Monitor. Once you can see who’s using your domain, you’ll know what to authorize and what to shut off.

Getting visibility into your domain is just the first step to improving its reputation. Once you identify who’s using your domain, you can lock it down to secure a good reputation and continue sending mail.

Frequently asked questions about domain reputation checks

How do I check my domain reputation?

Use a combination of free tools. Google Postmaster Tools shows how Gmail views your domain. Sender Score provides a 0-100 rating based on spam complaints and volume. Valimail’s Domain Checker shows your authentication status (SPF, DKIM, DMARC). Check multiple sources because each provider evaluates reputation differently. If you need to check your domain, use Valimail’s free DKIM checker.

What is a good domain reputation score?

It depends on the source. Aim for a Gmail spam rate under 0.1%, a Sender Score of 80 or higher, no blocklist listings, and DMARC at enforcement. There’s no universal score, so a healthy domain looks good across all of them.

Why is my domain reputation bad?

Common causes include high spam complaint rates (above 0.1%), sending to old or unengaged lists, hitting spam traps, sudden spikes in email volume, missing email authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), or someone spoofing your domain. Check your DMARC reports to see if unauthorized senders are damaging your reputation.

How long does it take to improve domain reputation?

It depends on how damaged your reputation is and what’s causing the problem. Minor issues can improve in a few weeks with better list hygiene and consistent sending. Severe reputation damage (blocklisting, high spam rates) can take 1-3 months of clean sending practices. There’s no quick fix—mailbox providers need to see sustained improvement.

Does email authentication affect domain reputation?

Yes. Proper SPF, DKIM, and DMARC authentication signals to mailbox providers that you’re a legitimate sender. It also prevents attackers from spoofing your domain, which can destroy your reputation if they send spam using your name. Authentication alone won’t fix a bad reputation, but missing authentication makes everything worse.

Get started for free
with Monitor

Start your path to DMARC enforcement with a panoramic view of the traffic being sent on your behalf.
No trial offers, credit cards, or obligations.

Explore all Valimail
has to offer

Go one step further than visibility…Take action! Reach DMARC enforcement faster. Stay compliant with evolving sender requirements. All while protecting your brand.

[UPCOMING WEBINAR] Valimail Product Release: Get Better Brand Protection and Brand Impressions – Register HERE